When to Update Your Home Insurance Coverage

Most homeowners get insurance when they buy their home and never think about it again. This passive approach can cost you thousands, either in uncovered claims when you're underinsured or in wasted premiums when you're overinsured. Your insurance needs change as your life and property change. Here's exactly when to update your coverage.

See our full comparison at homebeehub.

Annual Policy Renewal (Every Year)

Your policy renews annually, and this is your baseline opportunity to review and adjust coverage. Don't just auto-renew without checking.

What to Review at Renewal

Premium changes: If your premium increased more than 5-10%, investigate why. Construction cost inflation, claims frequency in your area, or changes to your credit score can drive increases.

Coverage limits: Verify your dwelling coverage still reflects current rebuild costs. Construction costs fluctuate, sometimes increasing 10-15% in a single year during material shortages.

Deductible: If your emergency fund has grown, consider increasing your deductible to save 10-20% on premiums.

Discounts: Confirm all applicable discounts are applied. New home discounts expire after 5-10 years, but you might qualify for claims-free discounts.

When to Shop Around

If your renewal premium increases more than 10%, get comparison quotes from 2-3 other insurers. Homeowners who switch after significant rate increases save an average of $380 per year.

Even without rate increases, shop around every 2-3 years. Insurance companies adjust rates differently over time, and what was competitive three years ago might now be 20% overpriced.

Major Home Renovations or Improvements

Any significant renovation increases your home's value and rebuild cost, requiring coverage updates.

Kitchen Remodel ($30,000+)

A major kitchen renovation can add $50,000-$100,000 to rebuild costs. If you spend $75,000 on a kitchen remodel, your rebuild cost increases by roughly that amount. Increase dwelling coverage accordingly.

Also notify your insurer about upgraded appliances, which may exceed standard personal property limits for electronics and appliances.

Bathroom Remodel ($20,000+)

Like kitchens, bathroom renovations increase rebuild costs. A $40,000 master bath remodel should trigger a $30,000-40,000 increase in dwelling coverage.

Home Additions

Adding square footage directly increases rebuild cost. A 500-square-foot addition typically costs $100,000-$200,000 and should increase your dwelling coverage by the same amount.

Important: Notify your insurer before starting construction. Many policies require notification of major projects, and some offer builders risk coverage during construction.

Finished Basement

Finishing a basement adds livable space, increasing rebuild cost by $50,000-$100,000+. Update coverage to reflect this value increase.

New Roof

A new roof doesn't typically require coverage increases, but it qualifies you for discounts. Notify your insurer after roof replacement to receive 5-15% premium reduction. Over time, this saves $100-$300 per year.

Swimming Pool Installation

Installing a pool increases your property value and liability risk. Increase your liability coverage from $300,000 to at least $500,000, and consider a $1-2 million umbrella policy. Pool-related injuries are expensive, with settlements often exceeding $300,000.

Pool installation also typically increases premiums by 10-20%, or $150-$300 per year.

Purchasing Expensive Items

Standard home insurance has sublimits for certain categories of personal property. Expensive purchases often exceed these limits.

Jewelry ($5,000+)

Standard policies cover only $1,500-$2,500 in jewelry per claim. If you buy a $10,000 engagement ring, add a scheduled personal property rider (also called a floater). Cost: approximately 1-2% of item value annually, so $100-$200/year for a $10,000 ring.

Art and Collectibles ($5,000+)

Fine art and collectibles typically have $2,500-$5,000 sublimits. Schedule valuable pieces individually. Get professional appraisals and add riders covering full replacement value.

Home Office Equipment ($5,000+)

If you have $15,000 in computers, monitors, and office equipment, standard personal property coverage might not fully protect it. Electronics sublimits range from $2,500-$5,000.

Consider: Business property endorsement if equipment is used for business, or increased electronics sublimits for personal equipment.

Musical Instruments ($3,000+)

Professional musicians should schedule expensive instruments. A $8,000 guitar needs a separate rider for full protection, both at home and when transported.

Life Changes

Getting Married

Combining households typically means more belongings. Review personal property coverage to ensure it's adequate for your combined possessions.

Also consider: Increasing liability coverage if your combined net worth exceeds $500,000, adding umbrella policy for additional protection, and combining policies might qualify you for multi-policy discounts.

Having Children

Children increase liability risk, especially teenagers. Once kids start driving, your liability risk multiplies. Consider increasing home liability to $500,000 and adding a $1-2 million umbrella policy.

Getting a Dog

Dog ownership increases liability risk. Some breeds (Pit Bulls, Rottweilers, German Shepherds) may not be covered or require additional premium.

Before getting a dog: Check if your insurer covers the breed, consider increasing liability coverage to $500,000, and verify medical payments coverage is at least $5,000.

Starting a Home Business

Home insurance doesn't cover business-related claims or business property. If you start a home business, get separate business insurance or add a home business endorsement.

What's at risk without business coverage: Client injuries at your home, damage to client property, business equipment theft or damage, and professional liability claims.

Retirement

Retiring often means being home more, which can reduce claim risk. Some insurers offer retiree discounts of 5-10%.

Also review: Whether you're still adequately protected, if you can increase deductibles to save money, and whether coverage amounts still make sense.

Neighborhood or Property Changes

Installing Security System

Monitored security systems qualify for 10-20% premium discounts, saving $150-$300 per year. Notify your insurer immediately after installation to start receiving the discount.

Removing Swimming Pool

If you remove your pool or hot tub, notify your insurer. This typically reduces premiums by 10-15%, saving $150-$300 annually.

Major Tree Removal

Removing large trees near your home can reduce risk and sometimes qualify for discounts, especially if they were dead or diseased trees that posed damage risk.

Natural Disaster Risk Changes

If FEMA updates flood maps and your property moves into or out of a flood zone, review your flood insurance needs. Being moved out of a flood zone can save $1,500-$3,000 per year.

Paying Off Your Mortgage

Once your mortgage is paid off, you're no longer required to carry insurance. However, dropping coverage is financial suicide. Instead, review your coverage for potential savings:

Consider higher deductibles: With no lender requirements, you can choose any deductible. Increasing from $1,000 to $2,500 saves $300-$500 per year.

Review coverage amounts: Ensure you're not overinsured. Get a fresh rebuild cost estimate and adjust coverage if needed.

Shop around: Without lender requirements to navigate, switching insurers is simpler. Get competitive quotes.

After Filing a Claim

After any claim, review your coverage at next renewal:

Expect premium increases: One claim typically raises premiums 9-20%. Two claims can increase rates 30-40%.

Claims-free discount lost: If you had a 10% claims-free discount, filing a claim removes it.

Consider shopping: Some insurers penalize claims more than others. If your rate jumps 25%+, get competitive quotes. Another insurer might offer better rates despite your claim history.

Market Value Increases

If your home's market value increases significantly (20%+ in a year or two), evaluate whether rebuild costs increased proportionally.

Important distinction: Market value and rebuild cost aren't the same. In hot real estate markets, land value might drive market price increases while rebuild cost stays flat. Don't automatically increase coverage just because your home's market value increased.

Get a rebuild cost estimate every 3-5 years to ensure accuracy.

Construction Cost Inflation

Material and labor costs fluctuate. During 2021-2023, construction costs increased 25-40% due to supply chain issues. Your 2020 rebuild estimate of $300,000 might be $380,000 by 2023.

Many insurers automatically adjust dwelling coverage annually for inflation (using a home inflation guard endorsement). Verify yours does this, and confirm the inflation adjustment rate is reasonable (typically 4-8% annually).

Creating a Review Schedule

Set reminders to review coverage:

Annually at renewal: Review all coverage, discounts, and premium

After any renovation: Update dwelling coverage

After expensive purchases: Add riders if needed

Every 2-3 years: Shop around for competitive rates

Every 3-5 years: Get professional rebuild cost estimate

Taking 30 minutes once per year to review your insurance can save you hundreds of dollars annually and prevent devastating coverage gaps.